Melee training: Difference between revisions

707 bytes removed ,  15:43, 9 November 2022
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 550: Line 550:
|-
|-
|{{plink|Saradomin sword}}
|{{plink|Saradomin sword}}
|70 [[Attack]]
|70 Attack
|[[Slash]]
|Slash
|[[Strength]]
|Strength
| +82 [[Slash]]<br/>
| +82 Slash<br/>
+82 [[Strength]]
+82 Strength
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Saradomin sword}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Saradomin sword}}}}
|The Saradomin sword is a much more affordable Strength training weapon than anything above it on this list. Against lower defence monsters such as Yaks, the Saradomin sword will on average do higher damage per second than the Staff of the dead due to its higher strength. However, this sword's lack of a shield and the staff's magic capabilities and melee accuracy make the staff usually more desirable if you can afford it.
|The Saradomin sword is a much more affordable Strength training weapon than anything above it on this list. Against lower defence monsters such as Yaks, the Saradomin sword will on average do higher damage per second than the Staff of the dead due to its higher strength. However, this sword's lack of a shield and the staff's magic capabilities and melee accuracy make the staff usually more desirable if you can afford it.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Sarachnis cudgel}}
|{{plink|Sarachnis cudgel}}
|65 [[Attack]]
|65 Attack
|[[Crush]]
|Crush
|[[Strength]]
|Strength
| +93 [[Crush]]<br/>
| +93 Crush<br/>
+76 [[Strength]] (dragon defender)
+76 Strength (dragon defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Sarachnis cudgel}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Sarachnis cudgel}}}}
|The Sarachnis cudgel is typically not used for training, as it has only minor benefits over the [[Dragon scimitar]] and has a 5 Attack higher requirement to wield, and when compared to the higher tier weapons that require 70+ Attack such as the [[Saradomin sword]] and [[Staff of the dead]] it's outclassed in terms of melee strength. However, the cudgel can pull ahead in rare cases where the target is vulnerable to crush.
|The Sarachnis cudgel is typically not used for training, as it has only minor benefits over the Dragon scimitar and has a 5 Attack higher requirement to wield, and when compared to the higher tier weapons that require 70+ Attack such as the Saradomin sword and Staff of the dead it's outclassed in terms of melee strength. However, the cudgel can pull ahead in rare cases where the target is vulnerable to crush.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Viggora's chainmace}}
|{{plink|Viggora's chainmace}}
|60 [[Attack]]<br/>
|60 Attack<br/>
|[[Crush]]
|Crush
|[[Strength]]
|Strength
| +91 [[Crush]]<br/>
| +91 Crush<br/>
+72 [[Strength]] (dragon defender)
+72 Strength (dragon defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Viggora's chainmace (u)}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Viggora's chainmace (u)}}}}
|This is tied for the best training weapon for all attack styles at level 60 with the Dragon Scimitar, without having to be charged or do any quests. If charged, an additional 50% melee accuracy and damage boost is applied when attacking any NPC in the Wilderness, making this weapon often better than every other weapon as the fastest way to train if done in the wilderness. However, it is significantly more expensive than the Dragon Scimitar and poses a threat of money loss (in charges) if killed in the wilderness. Additionally, the mace is slightly less accurate than the Dragon Scimitar when paired with one of the various [[Dragon defender|defenders]], as defenders generally provide higher offensive stab/slash bonus than crush bonus.
|This is tied for the best training weapon for all attack styles at level 60 with the Dragon Scimitar, without having to be charged or do any quests. If charged, an additional 50% melee accuracy and damage boost is applied when attacking any NPC in the Wilderness, making this weapon often better than every other weapon as the fastest way to train if done in the wilderness. However, it is significantly more expensive than the Dragon Scimitar and poses a threat of money loss (in charges) if killed in the wilderness. Additionally, the mace is slightly less accurate than the Dragon Scimitar when paired with one of the various defenders, as defenders generally provide higher offensive stab/slash bonus than crush bonus.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Dragon scimitar}}
|{{plink|Dragon scimitar}}
|60 [[Attack]]<br/>
|60 Attack<br/>
[[Monkey Madness I]]
|Slash
|[[Slash]]
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +91 [[Slash]]<br/>
| +91 Slash<br/>
+72 [[Strength]] (dragon defender)
+72 Strength (dragon defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Dragon scimitar}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Dragon scimitar}}}}
|This is tied for the best training weapon for all attack styles at level 60 with the Viggora's Chainmace. In addition, the Dragon scimitar is a '''''much''''' cheaper alternative to all of the weapons listed above, making it very popular even among some high level players. For Attack and Defence training, it should be replaced with the [[Abyssal whip]] as soon as one can afford and equip it.
|This is tied for the best training weapon for all attack styles at level 60 with the Viggora's Chainmace. In addition, the Dragon scimitar is a '''''much''''' cheaper alternative to all of the weapons listed above, making it very popular even among some high level players. For Attack and Defence training, it should be replaced with the Abyssal whip as soon as one can afford and equip it.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Dragon sword}}
|{{plink|Dragon sword}}
|60 [[Attack]]
|60 Attack
|[[Stab weapons|Stab]]
|Stab
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +90 [[Stab]]<br/>+69 [[Strength]] (dragon defender)
| +90 <br/>+69 Strength (dragon defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Dragon sword}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Dragon sword}}}}
|This is comparable to the [[Dragon scimitar]] in stats, but without the quest requirement of [[Monkey Madness I]].
|This is comparable to the Dragon scimitar in stats.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Leaf-bladed battleaxe}}
|{{plink|Leaf-bladed battleaxe}}
|65 [[Attack]]<br/>
|65 Attack<br/>
55 [[Slayer]]
55 Slayer
|[[Crush]]
|Crush
|[[Strength]]
|Strength
| +96 [[Slash]]<br/>
| +96 Slash<br/>
+95 [[Crush]]
+95 Crush
+98 [[Strength]] (dragon defender)
+98 Strength (dragon defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Leaf-bladed battleaxe}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Leaf-bladed battleaxe}}}}
|This weapon has the highest strength bonus in the game for a single handed weapon. It also has the second highest Crush attack bonus for a single handed weapon. This weapon is great to use against beasts which are weak to crush.
|This weapon has the highest strength bonus in the game for a single handed weapon. It also has the second highest Crush attack bonus for a single handed weapon. This weapon is great to use against beasts which are weak to crush.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Dragon longsword}}
|{{plink|Dragon longsword}}
|60 [[Attack]]<br/>
|60 Attack<br/>
[[Lost City]]
|Slash
|[[Slash]]
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +93 [[Slash]]
| +93 Slash
+77 [[Strength]] (dragon defender)
+77 Strength (dragon defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Dragon longsword}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Dragon longsword}}}}
|A viable alternate training weapon before being able to use the [[Dragon scimitar]] since [[Monkey Madness I]] is a much longer and harder quest than [[Lost City]]. It should be noted that the [[Dragon longsword]] attacks 1 game tick slower than the Dragon scimitar, making it less damage per second than the Dragon scimitar for training.
|A viable alternate training weapon before being able to use the Dragon scimitar. It should be noted that the Dragon longsword attacks 1 game tick slower than the Dragon scimitar, making it less damage per second than the Dragon scimitar for training.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Leaf-bladed sword}}
|{{plink|Leaf-bladed sword}}
|50 [[Attack]]<br/>
|50 Attack<br/>
55 [[Slayer]]
55 Slayer
|[[Stab]]
|Stab
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +67 [[Stab]]<br/>+50 [[Strength]] (no defender)
| +67 Stab<br/>+50 Strength (no defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Leaf-bladed sword}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Leaf-bladed sword}}}}
|This weapon is the second best option at 50 attack, behind the  [[Granite hammer]]. It requires 55 Slayer in addition to attack levels, so it's not used often outside of killing [[Turoth]]s and [[Kurask]]s.
|This weapon is the second best option at 50 attack, behind the  Granite hammer. It requires 55 Slayer in addition to attack levels, so it's not used often outside of killing Turoths and Kurasks.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Granite hammer}}
|{{plink|Granite hammer}}
|50 [[Attack]]
|50 Attack
50 [[Strength]]
50 Strength
|[[Crush]]
|Crush
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +57 [[Crush]]
| +57 Crush
+56 [[Strength]]
+56 Strength
(no defender)
(no defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Granite hammer}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Granite hammer}}}}
Line 636: Line 634:
|-
|-
|{{plink|Brine sabre}}
|{{plink|Brine sabre}}
|40 [[Attack]]
|40 Attack
|[[Slash]]
|Slash
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +47 [[Slash]]<br/>
| +47 Slash<br/>
+46 [[Strength]] (no defender)
+46 Strength (no defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Brine sabre}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Brine sabre}}}}
|A more expensive alternative to the [[Rune scimitar]], the [[Brine sabre]] boasts 2 additional slash and strength bonus, while also possessing a special attack. This makes it a popular training weapon for those who have the money.
|A more expensive alternative to the Rune scimitar, the Brine sabre boasts 2 additional slash and strength bonus, while also possessing a special attack. This makes it a popular training weapon for those who have the money.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Rune scimitar}}
|{{plink|Rune scimitar}}
|[[Attack|40 Attack]]
|40 Attack
|[[Slash]]
|Slash
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +45 [[Slash]]<br/>
| +45 Slash<br/>
+44 [[Strength]] (no defender)
+44 Strength (no defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Rune scimitar}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Rune scimitar}}}}
|The prototypical ''RuneScape'' weapon. This is your best bet for a cheap and effective training weapon at this level.
|The prototypical ''Near-Reality'' weapon. This is your best bet for a cheap and effective training weapon at this level.
|-
|-
|{{plink|Granite longsword}}
|{{plink|Granite longsword}}
|50 [[Attack]]<br />
|50 Attack<br />
50 [[Strength]]
50 Strength
|[[Slash]]
|Slash
|All Stats
|All Stats
| +65 [[Slash]]<br />+62 [[Strength]] (no defender)
| +65 Slash<br />+62 Strength (no defender)
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Granite longsword}}}}
|{{Coins|{{GEP|Granite longsword}}}}
|This weapon attacks slower than the [[Granite hammer]], [[Leaf-bladed sword]] and [[Rune scimitar]], making it usually worse overall.
|This weapon attacks slower than the Granite hammer, Leaf-bladed sword, and Rune scimitar, making it usually worse overall.
|-
|-
|Other [[Scimitars]]
|Other Scimitars
|< 40 [[Attack]]
|< 40 Attack
|[[Slash]]
|Slash
|All Stats
|All Stats
|Varies
|Varies
|Varies
|Varies
|Before reaching 40 Attack, it is recommended to train with the highest level [[scimitar]] that is available at your Attack level.
|Before reaching 40 Attack, it is recommended to train with the highest level scimitar that is available at your Attack level.
|}
|}


==Other equipment options==
==Other equipment options==
===Obsidian equipment + Berserker necklace===
===Obsidian equipment + Berserker necklace===
Wearing the [[obsidian platebody]], [[obsidian platelegs]], and the [[obsidian helmet]] gives a 10% damage and accuracy bonus to melee [[obsidian weapons]]. Wearing the [[berserker necklace]] also gives another 20% damage bonus to Obsidian weapons. Combining all four of these items with the [[Toktz-xil-ak]] (Obsidian sword) can actually give faster experience rates than anything in the table above against low-defence monsters, such as those in the [[Nightmare Zone]]. However, the set has below-average defence and does not allow the use of a [[Slayer helmet]]. If the player cannot use all five items, they should not be using the [[Toktz-xil-ak]].
Wearing the obsidian platebody, obsidian platelegs, and the obsidian helmet gives a 10% damage and accuracy bonus to melee obsidian weapons. Wearing the berserker necklace also gives another 20% damage bonus to Obsidian weapons. Combining all four of these items with the Toktz-xil-ak (Obsidian sword) can actually give faster experience rates than anything in the table above against low-defence monsters. However, the set has below-average defence and does not allow the use of a Slayer helmet. If the player cannot use all five items, they should not be using the Toktz-xil-ak.
===Void knight equipment===
===Void knight equipment===
Wearing the [[Void melee helm]] with the full [[Void Knight equipment]] set gives a 10% melee damage and accuracy bonus. This bonus accuracy makes it good against certain high-defence monsters like the [[Corporeal Beast]]. It is a good alternative for players with 42 combat stats who do not have access to high-strength gear. However, this set gives less strength than other melee equipment and has significantly lower melee and ranged defence, making it usually worse for training than high strength gear.
Wearing the Void melee helm with the full Void Knight equipment set gives a 10% melee damage and accuracy bonus. This bonus accuracy makes it good against certain high-defence monsters like the Corporeal Beast. It is a good alternative for players with 42 combat stats who do not have access to high-strength gear. However, this set gives less strength than other melee equipment and has significantly lower melee and ranged defence, making it usually worse for training than high strength gear.
===Dharok the Wretched's equipment===
===Dharok the Wretched's equipment===
Wearing a full set of [[Dharok the Wretched's equipment]] gives the set effect of increasing the player's damage the lower their remaining hitpoints are. Using a [[dwarven rock cake]] or [[locator orb]] the player can intentionally keep their health at 1&nbsp;hp while using [[Protection prayers]] to block all forms of damage. If the player has a source of prayer or damage block, such as by using [[prayer potions]], [[absorption]]s (Nightmare Zone only), or an altar, the player can safely use the set's effect to deal very high amounts of damage and gain fast experience. However, the set degrades after 15 hours of use and must be repaired in order to keep its stats.
Wearing a full set of Dharok the Wretched's equipment gives the set effect of increasing the player's damage the lower their remaining hitpoints are. Using a dwarven rock cake allows the player can intentionally keep their health at 1&nbsp;hp while using Protection prayers to block all forms of damage. If the player has a source of prayer or damage block, such as by using prayer potions, or an altar, the player can safely use the set's effect to deal very high amounts of damage and gain fast experience. However, the set degrades after 15 hours of use and must be repaired in order to keep its stats.
===Guthan the Infested's equipment===
===Guthan the Infested's equipment===
Wearing a full set of [[Guthan the Infested's equipment]] gives the set effect of a 25% chance to heal the player by the damage dealt. This set deals less damage than some of the best options on the list, but it allows players to train for long periods of time without banking to heal. Players can bring the four pieces in their inventory, train on their normal high-strength equipment, and switch to the Guthan's equipment only when their health gets low. Popular monsters for this tactic are [[gargoyle]]s, [[nechryael]], and [[Bandit (Bandit Camp)|bandits]]. However, the set degrades after 15 hours of use and must be repaired in order to keep its stats.
Wearing a full set of Guthan the Infested's equipment gives the set effect of a 25% chance to heal the player by the damage dealt. This set deals less damage than some of the best options on the list, but it allows players to train for long periods of time without banking to heal. Players can bring the four pieces in their inventory, train on their normal high-strength equipment, and switch to the Guthan's equipment only when their health gets low. Popular monsters for this tactic are gargoyles, nechryael, and bandits. However, the set degrades after 15 hours of use and must be repaired in order to keep its stats.


{{Training guides}}
{{Training guides}}